Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kasia Zaniewska's avatar

Thank you for sharing! I enjoide speed-testing it, especially preblematic areas were insighful

According to claude.ai:

## Analysis of Current Africa Coverage Through the Primer Framework

Based on recent headlines from major international news outlets, here's how current coverage measures against the Primer's principles:

### **What's Working Well:**

**Specificity Over Generalization:**

- Stories like "Nigerian university sparks outrage as staff check whether female students are wearing bras before exams" demonstrate country-specific reporting rather than continental generalizations

- Coverage of individual African footballers in MLS shows Africans as global participants, not victims

- The DRC-Rwanda peace deal coverage acknowledges distinct national interests rather than treating "Africa" as monolithic

**Showcasing Agency and Modernity:**

- The profile of architect Lesley Lokko "on a mission to transform architecture, fostering a new generation of 'more dynamic thinkers'" exemplifies centering African expertise and innovation

- Sports coverage positions African athletes as protagonists in global leagues

### **Problematic Patterns Persist:**

**The PIDIC Framework Still Dominates:**

- "Fighting in Africa's mineral-rich DRC killed over 3,000 in less than 2 weeks" leads with violence and conflict

- "Refugees Escaping Sudan Face Escalating Hunger" centers crisis and deprivation

- Multiple headlines about aid, refugee crises, and conflict reinforce the poverty-instability-disease narrative

**External Framing and "Saviorism":**

- "These former USAID staff are working to match donors to urgent, lifesaving aid projects" centers Western actors as problem-solvers

- "Trump wants to protect South Africa's White farmers" positions an American president as the key actor in South African affairs

- The peace deal story emphasizes Trump wanting credit rather than focusing on African diplomatic agency

**Missing African Voices:**

The Primer emphasizes prioritizing African experts and sources, but many stories still rely heavily on Western institutional perspectives, particularly in conflict and aid reporting.

### **The "Wainaina Test" Applied:**

Several headlines would fail Binyavanga Wainaina's satirical critiques:

- Use of "Africa" as catch-all in some headlines

- Focus on crisis and exotic dysfunction

- Centering of Western actors in African stories

### **Economic Complexity Underrepresented:**

The coverage lacks stories about:

- African tech unicorns and entrepreneurship

- Middle-class experiences and aspirations

- Intra-African trade and AfCFTA developments

- Cultural soft power exports beyond sports

### **Recommendations for Improvement:**

1. **Lead with Solutions**: When covering challenges, center African-led responses and innovations

2. **Diversify Story Types**: Balance crisis reporting with business, culture, and development stories

3. **Source African Experts**: Quote African analysts, academics, and civil society leaders as primary voices

4. **Show Economic Diversity**: Move beyond aid-dependency narratives to showcase entrepreneurship and trade

5. **Cover Intra-African Dynamics**: Prioritize African countries' relationships with each other, not just with the West

The analysis reveals that while some progress has been made in showcasing African agency and avoiding crude generalisations, much international coverage still falls into the problematic patterns the Primer seeks to address.

Expand full comment
Moky  Makura's avatar

Love this @Zain. How can Africa No Filter support ?

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts